Commonspirit Health

PBJ Takeaway: Commonspirit Health

19 Facilities10 States16% For-ProfitAvg. Overall Rating: 2.9Avg. Staffing Rating: 3.3Staffing Rating: 3.3

Commonspirit Health operates 19 nursing homes across 10 states, with 16% classified as for-profit. Its average CMS overall rating is 2.9 stars.

Across the portfolio, facilities report an average of 5.30 total nurse HPRD, including 1.30 RN hours, above the national ratio of 3.77 HPRD.

37% of Commonspirit Health facilities meet PBJ320 high-risk criteria (e.g. special focus facility, one-star overall, abuse icon). CMS reports a total of 15 fines ($841,048) for the chain's nursing homes.

320 Consulting

Commonspirit Health Key Metrics

Providers

States

Avg. Rating

2.9

Total Fines

$841,048

– Commonspirit Health

Special Focus Facilities (SFFs)

SFF Candidates

1-Star Overall

Cited for Abuse

Avg. CMS 5-Star Rating – Commonspirit Health

Overall

2.9

Health Inspection

2.7

Staffing

3.3

Quality Measures

4.1

Commonspirit Health Facilities

Nursing homes affiliated with this entity. Latest quarter staffing from CMS PBJ data. Click column headers to sort.

State	Provider	City	Total HPRD	RN HPRD	Overall Rating	Staffing Rating
CA	Community Convalescent Center of San Bernardino	San Bernardino	9.35	1.79	5	4
OH	Providence Care Center ⚠	Sandusky	3.21	0.59	1	1
CA	Bruceville Terrace - D/p Snf of Methodist Hospital	Sacramento	5.13	1.75	5	5
CA	Marian Regional Medical Center D/p Snf	Santa Maria	6.15	2.11	5	5
CA	St. John'S Hospital Camarillo D/p Snf	Camarillo	8.55	1.64	5	4
WI	Chi Franciscan Villa ⚠	South Milwaukee	3.56	0.54	1	1
WA	Bailey-Boushay House	Seattle	—	—	3	—
OH	St Clare Commons ⚠	Perrysburg	3.16	0.67	1	1
OH	The Gardens of St. Francis	Oregon	4.17	0.76	3	2
OH	Franciscan Care Ctr Sylvania ⚠	Toledo	2.83	0.56	1	1
CO	Mount St Francis Nursing Center ⚠	Colorado Springs	4.11	1.33	2	4
OH	St Leonard Hcc	Centerville	4.38	0.92	3	3
ND	Garrison Mem Hosp Nsg Fac	Garrison	5.79	2.24	2	4
NE	Chi Health St. Francis	Grand Island	8.15	3.25	4	4
MN	Lakewood Care Center	Baudette	4.78	0.70	4	5
MN	St Francis Home	Breckenridge	4.28	1.30	5	5
KY	Madonna Manor ⚠	Villa Hills	5.42	1.12	1	3
IA	Bishop Drumm Retirement Center ⚠	Johnston	3.65	0.82	2	4
CA	Community Hospital of San Bernardino Dp Snf	San Bernardino	7.95	1.13	3	3

Methodology

This dashboard uses CMS Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ) data (2017–2025), along with other public datasets (Provider Information, Affiliated Entity). State staffing standards via MACPAC (2022).

Metrics

Hours Per Resident Day (HPRD): Total staff hours ÷ average residents. Example: 350 hours for 100 residents = 3.5 HPRD.
Direct Care (excl. Admin, DON): Hours per resident day for direct care staff only (RN, LPN, CNA, NAtrn, MedAide), excluding administrative and supervisory roles.
Contract Staff %: Share of hours provided by contract staff.
Census: Average number of residents during the period.

Note: Some states set minimums (e.g., NJ, CA, NY at 3.5 HPRD); a federal 3.48 minimum was recently overturned (2025). A 2001 federal study linked 4.1 HPRD to better outcomes in that study. Staffing needs vary by resident acuity (case-mix), day, and shift. Estimates on PBJ Takeaway assume roughly 60% of staff are CNAs.

Data transparency

The PBJ Dashboard pulls directly from CMS data and is carefully vetted for accuracy. Still, sometimes a bug sneaks into the jelly. That could mean: a systemic CMS data reporting issue (e.g., Q2 2017 contract staffing, missing data in 2020 due to COVID) or there could be a coding error on our part. If you spot something that looks off, please let me know via the contact form so I can set things right.

Request custom PBJ analysis for litigation and investigative reporting.Request custom PBJ analysis.